The Climax of a Rivalry: The Battle of Jutland

Beatty's Battlecruisers at the Battle of Jutland | Courtesy of Wikipedia Commons

It’s May of 1916, war rages across the world as Great Britain and her allies are locked in a life or death struggle against the mighty German Empire. Chaos and death reign on the battlefields of France and Russia. However, separate from the carnage of trench warfare and No Man’s Land, lie two powerful forces: the British and German fleets.1 The British Grand Fleet consisted of thirty-three dreadnought battleships, the most powerful ships that had ever been built, and over one hundred other smaller vessels; it was the most powerful fleet in the world. The German High Seas fleet consisted of eighteen dreadnought battleships and was supported by over one hundred smaller vessels as well, and it was second only to the British fleet. For the duration of the war, the two sides had waited with bated breath for an opportunity to  engage each other. Finally, at the close of May 1916, that opportunity presented itself.2

At the end of May 1916, the British government became aware that the German High Seas Fleet was planning a major operation. They did not know where it would take place, but, at noon on the 30th, the government ordered the Grand Fleet to proceed to the North Sea. Commander of the fleet Sir John Jellicoe and his second in command, Vice Admiral Sir David Beatty, jumped into action immediately upon receiving orders. They sent signal flags up the mast of their ships indicating to the fleet that combat orders had been received. Immediately, the naval base at Scapa Flow was filled with the sights and sounds of blowing whistles, rowboats moving to and fro delivering crew members to their assigned ships, and black smoke billowing out of the funnels of the great steel behemoths. By nine that evening, the Grand Fleet was ready to put to sea. Altogether, Jellicoe and Beatty commanded a force of 150 ships, including 28 dreadnought battleships and 9 battlecruisers. It was an extremely powerful force.3

The Grand Fleet assembled in 1914 | Courtesy of Wikipedia Commons

Meanwhile, across the North Sea at the German port of Wilhelmshaven, the High Seas Fleet was making its own preparations to put to sea. Commander of the High Seas Fleet, Reinhard Scheer, had been waiting for weeks for the opportunity to sail his fleet into the North Sea. Finally, with the opportunity at hand, Scheer had prepared 16 dreadnoughts along with 5 battlecruisers. In all, his fleet numbered just 99 ships, but the Germans were not to be underestimated, as they were extremely skilled seamen. One hour past midnight on the 31st of May, the High Seas Fleet was at sea, steaming north to hunt for the enemy fleet. So it was that the two most powerful fleets in the world were now on a collision course, each vying for a decisive victory, but only one side could win.4

The rivalry between the British and German navies can be traced back to the 1880s. When Kaiser Wilhelm II of Germany ascended to the throne in 1888, Germany’s foreign policy changed considerably. Before Wilhelm’s accession, German Chancellor Otto von Bismarck had been content with Germany’s place as the leading power on the European continent. However, the new Kaiser had a different idea for Germany’s place in the world. He believed that the German Empire should be the greatest nation, not just on the continent, but also in the world. To achieve that goal he needed one thing, a powerful navy. Since he was a small child, Wilhelm dreamed of a navy that he could be proud of. All the way back to his holidays at Osborne House in England with his grandmother Queen Victoria, the Kaiser remembered the beautiful ships of the Royal Navy at Portmouth. Now, as emperor of Germany, he had the opportunity to build his own fleet, and in doing so, increase the power of his nation. Within four months of the beginning of his reign four new battleships were ordered. Thus, the German navy began to grow, but it was not the Kaiser who would catapult the German Navy to first rate status; rather, it was a man by the name of Alfred Tirpitz.5

Alfred Tirpitz, “The Father of the German Navy,” was at one time a mere sailor in the fledgling German fleet. No one could have imagined that he would become the most important figure in German naval history. However, his fortune changed, dramatically, at a dinner party in 1890 when Kaiser Wilhelm asked Tirpitz what his vision for the future of the navy was. When Tirpitz replied, “Germany must have battleships,” the Kaiser became so enthusiastic that nine months later he asked Tirpitz to become Chief of Staff to the High Command, and to develop a strategy for a new German fleet.6 From that moment on, Tirpitz’s star was on the rise, and by June of 1897, he was appointed Navy Minister. It was in this role that Tirpitz would transform the German navy into a force to be reckoned with.7

Immediately upon entering office, Tirpitz delivered a memorandum to the Kaiser entitled “General Considerations on the Constitution of Our Fleet According to Ship Classes and Designs.” In it he stated that Great Britain was the most dangerous enemy in regard to Germany, and that the new German fleet must be powerful enough to challenge the Royal Navy. Tirpitz believed that in order to challenge the Royal Navy, nineteen battleships would have to be built within nine years. The implications of this memorandum were extraordinary. Britain had been designated as the enemy of Germany, and this was the main reason for the construction of a new German fleet. Tirpitz then launched a public relations campaign in which he successfully convinced not only the German Parliament, but also the German people that a powerful fleet was a necessity for national defense. Finally, in March of 1898, the German Parliament passed the 1898 Naval Bill, which set aside funds for the construction of nineteen battleships. It was a huge success, but it was clearly not enough, and in 1900, a second Naval Bill was passed that set aside more funds for an additional nineteen battleships. The new Naval Bill set Germany on a very dangerous path: a collision course with Great Britain.8

Indeed, the British government had been watching developments in Germany with increasing alarm. When the second Naval Bill was passed it felt like an insult. The whole existence of Great Britain depended on her mastery of the seas, and the nation had always prided itself on having the world’s greatest navy. Now, Germany was poised to take that distinction from her. The British government was not going to sit idly by as the Germans usurped their position as the leading naval power. Under the direction of First Sea Lord, Jacky Fisher, the British government, weary of German naval expansion, consolidated its battleships closer to Great Britain. Also, Fisher oversaw the construction of H.M.S Dreadnought, the revolutionary vessel that became the model battleship for every other navy in the world. After that, Britain and Germany became embroiled in building bigger and better battleships, preparing for the battle they knew was coming.9

As dawn broke on the morning of May 31st, the British fleet divided into two squadrons that were seventy miles apart. Admiral Beatty’s squadron included six battlecruisers and four battleships, while Admiral Jellicoe commanded the rest of the fleet. For hours Beatty’s squadron sailed ahead without encountering the enemy, but that all changed at 2:20 in the afternoon, when the British destroyer Galeta sighted two German cruisers. At 2:28 Geleta open fired, and the first shots of the Battle of Jutland were out. Beatty reacted quickly, with the signal “Action Stations,” and the crews of the vessels began preparing for action. Men rushed to and fro pulling out fire hoses and stocking water, food, and other provisions in gun turrets. Within minutes, the decks of the entire squadron had been cleared, and the men were hunkered down inside the gun turrets ready for action. At 3:45 Beatty arranged his ships into a line of battle. All of his battlecruisers followed each other at five hundred yard intervals, and the four battleships followed seven miles behind. The German forces, too, had arranged themselves in a battle line, and they got the first shots out against their opponents. The Germans were on target almost immediately, and their shells struck the British battlecruisers with metal shattering force. After ten minutes, Beatty’s forces finally found their targets, and began scoring hits.  Finally, both sides had engaged; the sound of their guns rang out across the sea like thunderclaps; it was truly a clash of the titans. 10

At 4:05 disaster struck the British squadron. The battlecruiser H.M.S Indefatigable had been engaged with the German vessel, Von der Tann, and had suffered significant damage. Finally, the German battlecruiser fired two last shots that penetrated her superstructure, and thirty seconds later she blew up. The wreck of the battlecruiser belched flames and smoke, and the vessel rolled over on her side and sank, taking with her 1,017 people. Only two crewmen survived. However, there was barely time to comprehend that loss, when H.M.S Queen Mary, beleaguered by the fire of two German vessels, exploded and was also engulfed by fire and smoke. At the same time there was a false report that another battlecruiser had been destroyed, at that Beatty uttered the famous phrase, “There seems to be something wrong with our bloody ships today.”11 Indeed there was something wrong with the British battlecruisers that day.12

H.M.S Queen Mary blows up | Courtesy of Wikipedia Commons
In World War I, the British had the world’s most powerful and best trained fleet. So why then, when the opportunity presented itself, did the British lose two of the most powerful warships in their fleet so suddenly? The answer lies in their regulations. In order to ensure that their navy ran smoothly, the British put in place many useful regulations. From regulations concerning the health of crew to the correct maintenance of ships, it is safe to say that the British had all the major bases covered. In regard to the Battle of Jutland, one regulation was extremely important. In the summer of 1914, the British government allowed the Royal Navy to carry an additional forty shells of ammunition. In order to put those shells to proper use, a highly flammable substance known as cordite, also had to be provided in greater quantity. However, the government wanted to be cautious. Along with the cordite charges they also provided protective casings that would nullify the flammable qualities of the cordite charges. The government then stipulated that these cases, when they contained cordite charges, were not to be stored near gun turrets. These measures, if observed properly, ensured the safety of ships at sea. There was one problem with these regulations: they slowed down the rate of fire during combat. It was commonly accepted in the Royal Navy that the opponent that fired faster would win the battle. Thus, it was common practice to ignore government regulations, and have cordite charges exposed beneath gun turrets. This is exactly what happened with the battlecruisers at Jutland. With exposed cordite underneath their active gun turrets, coupled with the damage they already received, they were essentially powder kegs waiting to explode.13

Now in command of just four battlecruisers and four battleships, Beatty decided to continue the pursuit of his German opponent. Unknown to Beatty, his German adversary, Franz von Hipper, wanted him to follow him. Hipper intended to rendezvous with the rest of the High Seas Fleet, and in doing so, he hoped to surprise Beatty and beat him outright. Hipper ordered his forces to turn south, and Beatty, eager for engagement, took the bait. At 4:35, the British battle squadrons saw something they’d hoped they would never see: the gray hulls and tall masts of the entire High Seas Fleet were bearing down on them. For Hipper, it seemed that victory was now within German grasp. Beatty’s forces were alone against the entire German fleet. Beatty, when he saw the German fleet, ordered his forces to make a 180 degree turn and steam north. With his four battlecruisers and four battleships, Beatty headed north, being chased all the while by the entire German fleet. The German fleet opened up on the retreating British force. The shots fired by the German battleships were extremely accurate, and it seemed, for a time, that the British force was in grave danger. However, the four battleships at the rear of the line provided excellent cover. Still, the British force was taking a pounding. Beatty had to rendezvous with Jellicoe, and soon.14

Beatty’s luck changed at 5:45 that evening, when he spotted the rear guard of the Grand Fleet. Now it was the Germans turn to get the shock of their lives. When the High Seas fleet pursued Beatty, they had had no idea that he was leading them straight into the entire Grand Fleet. Indeed, Jellicoe had had enough foresight to arrange every single one of his ships into a single battle line. When the German fleet emerged from a smokescreen, it saw laid out before them almost every vessel in the Grand Fleet. The full power of the Grand Fleet now opened up on the High Seas Fleet. However, Admiral Scheer, commander of the High Seas Fleet, never panicked. Instead, he ordered his smaller vessels to pop smoke screens while the battleships turned away. However, Jellicoe was relentless, and he pursued the High Seas Fleet, crossing in front of it once more, allowing his ships to continue firing. There was, however, one thing Jellicoe was apprehensive about: a torpedo attack. With the Germans on the run, Jellicoe thought that Scheer might order a torpedo attack to guard the German retreat. With this in mind, Jellicoe elected not to follow the High Seas Fleet, which was in retreat. Still, throughout the evening, the Grand Fleet continued to search for the German fleet, and even though it was spotted multiple times, no orders were given to pursue the enemy.15 By June 2nd both fleets returned to their bases to assess their damages. In all, British major losses included the battlecruisers Indefatigable and Queen Mary, and also a third battlecruiser that had met the same fate as the others later in the battle, the Invincible, and three other large vessels along with eight smaller vessels. The German fleet suffered too. They had lost three large ships, including the battlecruiser Lutzow and the old battleship Pommern along with eight smaller vessels.16 Causalities were also high. The British lost 11,163 men, while the Germans lost 2,551 men.17

The Battle of Jutland was a quagmire. For the British, it forced them to accept the fact that the German Navy was an extremely powerful opponent, and that they had matched the British blow for blow. The improper storage of cordite was also an issue that had to be addressed. It appeared as if the commanders of the fleet had allowed their subordinates to disobey safety regulations, a practice that had to be put to an end. Still, British sea power was not compromised. All of the fleets’ battleships had survived, and Scheer had retreated multiple times during the course of the battle, and retreating does not win battles. The Germans, at first, hailed the Battle of Jutland as a victory, but the reality was far different. Great Britain’s fleet was still intact, and control of the North Sea remained firmly in British hands. Both sides were forced to admit that the Battle of Jutland was not the decisive battle they had been planning for for decades. However, Jutland was the most significant naval battle during the war, and it had a profound effect on both the British and German navies.

Battle of Jutland May 31st, 1916 | Courtesy of Wikipedia Commons
  1.  World War I Reference Library, 2002, s.v. “The War at Sea.”
  2. Robert K. Massie, Castles of Steel: Britain, Germany and the Winning of the Great War at Sea (New York: Random House, 2003), 566.
  3. Robert K. Massie, Castles of Steel: Britain, Germany and the Winning of the Great War at Sea (New York: Random House, 2003), 575-577.
  4. Robert K. Massie, Castles of Steel: Britain, Germany and the Winning of the Great War at Sea (New York: Random House, 2003), 563-564.
  5. Robert K. Massie, Dreadnought: Britain, Germany, and the Coming of the Great War (New York: Random House, 1991), 76-77, 150, 163-164.
  6. Alfred Tirpitz, quoted in Robert K. Massie, Dreadnought: Britain, Germany, and the Coming of the Great War (New York: Random House, 1991), 168.
  7. Robert K. Massie, Dreadnought: Britain, Germany, and the Coming of Great War (New York: Random House, 1991), 168, 172.
  8. Robert K. Massie, Dreadnought: Britain, Germany, and the Coming of the Great War (New York: Random House, 1991), 177-180.
  9. Robert K. Massie, Dreadnought: Britain, Germany, and the Coming of the Great War (New York: Random House, 1991), 461-462.
  10. Robert K. Massie, Castles of Steel: Britain, Germany, and the Winning of the Great War at Sea (New York: Random House, 2003), 579, 583-593.
  11. David Beatty, quoted in Robert K. Massie, Castles of Steel: Britain, Germany, and the Winning of the Great War at Sea (New York: Random House, 2003), 596.
  12. Robert K. Massie, Castles of Steel: Britain, Germany, and the Winning of the Great War at Sea (New York: Random House, 2003), 593-596.
  13.  Nicholas A. Lambert, “Our Bloody Ships” or “Our Bloody System”? Jutland and the Loss of the Battle Cruisers, 1916,” The Journal of Military History, Vol. 62, No. 1 (Jan., 1998): 29-55.
  14. Robert K. Massie, Castles of Steel: Britain, Germany, and the Winning of the Great War at Sea (New York: Random House, 2003), 597-603.
  15. Norman Friedman, Fighting the Great War at Sea: Strategy, Tactics, and Technology (Annapolis, Maryland: Naval Institute Press, 2014), 165-172.
  16. Robert K. Massie, Castles of Steel: Britain, Germany, and the Winning of the Great War at Sea (New York: Random House, 2003), 665.
  17. John Campbell, Jutland: Am Analysis of the Fighting (London: Conway Maratime Press, 1986), 338-341.
More from Christopher Hohman

Prelude to the Roman Empire: The Battle of Actium

The years 34-31 B.C.E. was a difficult time for the Roman Republic....
Read More

9 Comments

  • thank you for your use of pictures to illisturate the size and paths of the fleets. I really like that you were able to explain the rivalry between britian and germany and how that translated into the conflict that was had. You did an excellent job at making something less known relevant and intersting for the reader.

  • This article was so enjoyable to read. I find military history articles to be fascinating an fun to read. The images that were used were great because it goes well with what is being described in the article itself. It is interesting that Great Britain and Germany had an intense rivalry, and that they were enemies during the war. This was a great article.

  • This is an interesting article regarding a less-known event. This author was able to establish a historical detailed background that engaged the reader to continue reading on, as well as, informing the reader of important details of a forgotten battle that had been waged. I appreciate this article’s illustration of this brutal conflict that gives a new meaning to war strategy.

  • This article was a good read, was not only informative but it was also was very good at telling a story which kept the reader engaged while learning about the topic. I really enjoyed the images in this article they were very captivating and went well to give the reader images to help imagine what was happening. It went into much depth throughout, I just enjoyed it.

  • I loved how the author sets up the article. They really tell a story here rather than just accounting for war history…it makes for a wonderful read! I loved how a section of the article took the time to explain why and how the British and the Germans had such an intense rivalry. I myself am not proficient in war history, so such an explanation really helped me to understand the article better. I was interested to read that there were regulations to be followed, even in the heat of battle.

  • This was a great article. Not only was it interesting, it was also engaging and written in such a way that it keeps the reader wanting to know more and more about the battles. I really enjoyed the fact that you gave a detailed background of the matter and did so in a manner that added pertinent details to the article without making it boring and bogged down in historical facts. This article is a fun read and a read that tells the story of a very important battle.

  • The description given but the author made me feel like I was right there! This was a great article, well written and explained. I found it interesting that the Royal Navy had so many rules and regulations, but it is understandable. I also appreciated the images as they assist with further imagining the situation. It is crazy to find that in the end both sides did not feel like the battle went the way they hoped, yet is was a huge part of the overall war

  • This was a very fascinating and intriguing article! I like how this article focused more on a naval battle rather than the entirety of a war that spanned over a certain period of time. To me at least naval battles are an important part of our history that not many history books seem to cover, so thank you for being one of the first to do something like this!

  • Overall this is a well written and researched article. It stands out from the other military articles in that it chooses to cover a naval battle, particularly one from World War I which I feel are not as well known or frankly written about as much as some of their land based counterparts. The images are also quite striking and very well used throughout this piece.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.